New York Governor Vetoes State GRAS Bill in a Win for ASTA and the Spice Industry
New York Governor Kathy Hochul vetoed S1239-F, the Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act, on November 20, 2026. The bill had been a significant concern for many in the spice industry.
Why It Matters to the Spice Industry:
- No state reporting gate. The bill could have kept ingredients off New York shelves simply because state paperwork was missing, even when those ingredients are safe and legal under federal law. Many spices, spice extracts, and seasoning ingredients could have been caught up in that requirement.
- No state patchwork. A separate New York program would have added a second set of rules for one large market, and other states could have copied it.
- Lower compliance costs. Companies would have faced new state filings on top of federal requirements. That burden falls hardest on small and mid-sized businesses.
- The focus shifts to Washington. The FDA’s proposed transparency rule and GRAS reform in the next Congress will shape how spice ingredients are regulated. ASTA will continue to monitor both.
About the Bill:
The bill would have required the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets (AGM) to build and maintain a database of scientific reports for thousands of food ingredients. Any substance whose required information was not reported to AGM could no longer be sold or used in New York. The bill also would have banned three specific substances: FD&C Red No. 3, potassium bromate, and propylparaben.
In her veto message, the Governor said food ingredient oversight is “traditionally and more appropriately the role of the federal government.”
Related Resources
Now Available: Essential Regulatory Education On-Demand
One price, everything included: every 2026 Regulatory Workshop session plus the 10-part U.S. Spice Regulations 101 webinar series, all for $395.
President’s Update December 2024
ASTA Advocacy, News Updates, and Upcoming Events